I think envato should just give you a fix sum for referring some one say $1, it seems less but i have not had one person i have referred deposit anything so i have made no money! so i would be happy with $1
It seem quite similar to card already on the site just does not have a wow factor!
I would say it is the layer style and the flowery bit that lose it for me, but the design is clean!
not overly useful comment but i think it needs more wow factor, just to plain at the mo
I would add more colour look a bit plain, but the main thing for me me is the are no separating lines to break the design up i think this would help!
From the examples shown here so far i would have to say no. but that is beacuse all the things you have shown are not suitable for this site,
If you put up a real piece of design you have done your self it would be alot easy to judge!
I have some thing very similar to you picture but more detail and higher quality, it is already good to go just send me a message if your interested
I had the same thought the egg are not egg shaped this is big problem for a egg this along would probably have been enough to get it rejected
the text placement on the top and bottom buttons needs some work, it does not fill the buttons enough
If you make the eggs, egg shaped and just added alittle more detail and sort the text out it should be good to go!
The main issue for me is the cutting out and masking need alot more work this can bee seen at the top and bottom of the fence
It would be best to be careful when mixing photos and cartoons to make sure they fit well
I think it is just a bit too simple and the large text make this more apparent, a good start would be to reduce the size of the text then you could have a bit more white space.
might also be nice to see a colour that stands out well against the grey used.