Congratulations WizyLabs! You guys deserve it, keep up the good work
AlexPascal saidAnyways, the best is http://themeforest.net/item/unite-html-business-magazine-community-site/84401 unite.
Which fruit is the best?
+1 I loved this theme, it has great features, typography, design, etc. Simply ONE of the best! There are also other great ones, but just like al_m473 said it’s all about what kind of functionality want the theme to serve. Although if I had to choose based on overall design and functionality it would be Unite.
Thanks for the reply and the suggestion guys I will take them into account!
If you still need some more specific feedback regarding your file, I suggest you wait a bit for other author’s comments, or reply to the rejection e-mail asking the reviewer to give you some tips on how to make the file better.
Better yet, contact the reviewer via support who will happily help provide further clarification.
Thanks for the heads up guys, I really appreciate the responses! Although I already sent the reviewer an e-mail. I was looking what other things could make this package better (from multiple opinions).
Wow! What an achievement! I love your work man, keep it up
I am new to the Envato Marketplace (as an author) and I just submitted my first file three days ago only to find that it was rejected. I made sure that the file met up with the standards and I just can’t figure out why it wasn’t accepted.I was only left with these few words from the reviewer: This File Did Not Meet Our Criteria Your file has some well done design concepts, however it does not meet the current and very stringent quality guidelines and we can not accept your file at this time…
It would be great if I could get some feed back on this button pack.
Here is a screenshot: http://fallingarts.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/12/Preview.jpg
P.S. The watermark is only there so that someone wont get a hold of these icons if they find the image somehow. Skeptical but necessary measures
Thank you in Advance, FallingArts
Your theme is pretty nice but there is room for lots of improvements. The style is really nice (I like the background noise and textures) but don’t let it blind your judgement.
Your template lacks alignment – see how menu, slider and content areas are misaligned? I know that you were trying to align the content of boxes, not boxes themselves, but you should rework these areas to align nicely.
Footer is terrible – poor color choices. It looks like a complete mess right now and the vertical lines aren’t helping.
Something more about how theme is coded – most of your categories give 404 error.
Typography needs improvement – on your advanced formatting page I can see no vertical rhythm. List items are plain and need improvements too.
I don’t like the horizontal dividing lines – they should be more subtle. They’re also to close to text – some vertical padding/margins should improve that.
The dividing lines in sidebar should be more subtle too. Additional alignment for lists and calendar in sidebar is crucial too.
Adding features like AJAX contact form and lightbox effects for images will increase theme attractiveness and its value.I really wish you luck because I like your theme’s style. Hope you’ll improve it and you’ll get it accepted soon
Thank you so much, this was the kind of response I was looking for. When I have time, I will definitely revise those aspects and hopefully get this theme accepted on Themeforest
That’s the reason 99%. Anyway, i like your theme it’s really nice.If the reason for the rejection was 99% cause of the fact it’s generic the reviewer would have stated THAT . but the reviewer stated design issues, quality issues. Yet I don’t see where the “significant improvements” have to be done in the theme since I really like it. Sometimes I don’t think the generic rejection emails are pointing the right issues out.
Off topic: I really don’t understand how the reviewers can claim for originality while recommending in their rejection messages that the authors should take a look at the most popular themes. That does not make sense.Anyways, good luck with your theme! Greetings, GC
You read my mind on the originality aspect of it; I did find it a bit odd that they recommend you look at other themes to make your better. Also, thank you for the kind words
It looks pretty good and I believe it only need some minor changes to get accepted. I’d recommend increasing the spacing between widgets both in the sidebar and in the fotter and also increasing the line-height of the general body-text. Paz.
Thanks Paz I will definitely work on that