Do you have your own html/css framework or you use one of open source such as bootstrap, skeleton, 960gs etc..? If your theme is made using bootstrap, does it help in sales ?
Better option would be to introduce search function for comments, as when someone has problem with theme and there are 500+ comments, one need to go through all comments to findout if someone else had same problem like he did and if author answered that comment
Of this image:http://putuj.org/sammer/wp-content/themes/Sammer/images/customer.jpg
Trying to figure out but nothing. Not even whatthefont.com
Is it better to build wordpress theme that you plan to sell on themeforest with some boilerplate or from scratch ? How do you do it ? Or you have your own boilerplate ?
Probably not why you got rejected, but your slider is messed up. Second one is animating before first one got cleared up. Also their animations are somehow slow. Then on services, bottom accordion title is white on white background. Thats just quick look. Generaly, slider on front page takes some time to load.. Anyway I had very quick view. All in all good template, nothing unique, but could pass because of lots of customization that he offers.
Hm not sure, but text reminds me of old email templates that always placed to much information/text in one email. Also there is not enough white space. Then typography could be improved, text is small.