Don’t know if you remember but this also happened to us 7 month ago for our directory:: http://themeforest.net/forums/thread/envato-your-softdisable-action-is-unprofessional/129427
This action from Envato really has to stop, it’s a reputational risk not only for authors but also for the marketplace because customers don’t know anymore whether to trust the source or not especially when it comes to directory themes which are App oriented applications that customers use to generate revnues
our suggestion is the following:
If a theme gets soft-disabled then the item remains on the marketplace the puchase button gets disactivated and includes a sign/notice saying that this item is temporary soft-disabled you can consult the comments section and ask questions but cannot purchase it until the issue has been solved.like this we don’t need to receive thousands of emails of customers worried that we removed the item
its 1% different ( i mean images )
WOW! Congrats My sister U really Awesome and Good Luck for your future items
The Envato Mummy!
Another Halloween stuff here.
+1 and I want to share somethings thanks for open this thread.
I uploaded a new item in September 5, 2014 and reviewed September 7, 2014 soft reject 3-4 bugs its fine I am happy for soft reject.
After a lot of time works (23 days) I re submitted on October 4, 2014 and again, I wait 2 days for review then reivewed with new reasons;
Reason: Apologies for any confusion, different categories have different requirements. Not all previous changes were addressed with this item. The changes are not enough. When a change is requested it should be significant enough to change the look and feel of the site. Changing a few elements does not change the visual inconsistencies in your design. If you’re unsure how to proceed and need further feedback, you might consider asking for input from other community members and designers via our forums. http://themeforest.net/forums
He said you might consider asking for input from other community members and designers via our forums. huh? why? come on man you are reviewer please tell me what is wrong? why I ask forum? why I share my url? then its okey…
I changed all my template style then I re-submitted again with a lot of changes...
(October 6, 2014) after 1 day its reviewed with new reasons (5 new reasons)...
I am happy again because I seeing what is wrong now, I fixed all problems and re-submited again on October 7, 2014
then 2 days later reviewed and AGAIN SOFT REJECT reasons;
Reason: This item still needs to be developed a bit further. Focus on working with the typography. There are also minor spacing and alignment issues throughout. Currently, there are a lot of animations that are detracting from the design of this template.
same day I re-submitted again and after 3 days still waiting review…. 11 October..
WOW! Its very hardly perriod. I don’t know what can I say, I am very tired..