The borderline between logos and sfx is very misty, my uploads were replaced by reviewers twice, from futuristic sounds to logos and naoborot. In general, reviewers say that sound must have tonal elements to be considered as logo. I think in your case it’s enough to add some subtle tink to final point (or pad to noisy body, or something) to make it work as a logo.
I’m not expert From listening twice the only issue which sounds a bit weird for me is those two notes syncopated at 16ths. 2th and 3th ones in lead melody line. Maybe playing them more simply, straight in a beat, will sound better?
Phew, having too hot hands for experiments I lost profile page too.
Really fun this page is looking.
My guess is that after resubmission your item went to another reviewer, who had another opinion on it’s acceptability. You can open a ticket to support, because this case is obviously discussful (with reviewers) to solve.
I’ve missed that example too. Illegal reselling? Btw, I cannot find any penguins at AJ, so perhaps it’s untilled niche to fill (cannot even imagine how they sound).
+1 I vote. I’m not a buyer, just trying to imagine how he downloads many tracks to test with his project to find the right one – and what he must do then with all those preview(1), preview(2) or preview(83).
Made me understand English and speak understandable enough (I hope). For about a year, without any programmed studying, just by only reading and communicative practice.