Happy Holidays to the reviewers and keep up the good job
I built some forums for one of my web projects a couple months ago. You really need to sit down and find out what kind of features you would like in a forum.
For instance Categories (Parent Forums), Sub Categories (sub Forums), then Topics and Replies. Once you figure out your table structure everything else should come into play correctly.
This is possible to do, but the buyer would need to know some php knowledge (arrays) unless you want the coder to include a database class as well.
Even though the script seems bare bones it could be done properly. It is not just the look that reviewers look at so do not get all worked up about how it looks. You need to take into consideration multiple aspects of the project.
You need to look at how easy it can be integrated into other systems (CMS, WordPress, etc). Another good one is documentation. Not just inside the code, but outside the code. Not all clients have coding knowledge and they would like to implement the script into their own site. Having some kind of guide or document on how they do this can also be an improvement.
All I am trying to say is don’t get your self worked up about a script being rejected. Take some time, pen and paper and start going through a small checklist of items that could improve it such as documentation, etc.
The link you showed here describes not a script but a system. (As it contains a search, rating, image uploads, etc). There is no real item there describing what you are selling. (Is it the entire thing, or just the rating?)
Why not email the Reviewer and find out more information about why it was rejected?
Hopefully I did not come off as strong against anyone, I am just trying to be helpful. 
So you just trying to get it all from SQL ?
Have you tried using a Union Select?
select "fields" from comments_news
union select "fields" from comments_profil
union select "fields" from comments_status
order by date desc
All selects must have the same number of fields, and you can also try “order by 3 desc” where 3 is the field in the select you are referring to (so if the date field is last and you have 5 other fields (total 6) your order by would be “order by 6 desc”)
I think the forum are fine the way they are. A Rich Text or BBCode editor would be nice instead of typing in the html tags.
That is really the only thing I can see wrong.
I would think if they are a set of tags that say make Forms improved then it should be a “theme” and hence Theme Forest.
Thanks Jeffery, at least something (perhaps an Other in the selection, with not filling anything in).
Just to let the customer know that it is using a framework and they should look to see which one.
You can open a business account with them, it’s free. This will get rid of the those types of limits. You will need a Business License to send (fax) to them for verification.
I am in Canada so maybe their rules are different. I have never had problems with PayPal using my business account with them. I got verified (took a week) and since then (about 3 years ago) there has not been a single problem.
knocks on wood
Sure, on the right hand side you can see this image is suppose to be something. However I is broken and being linked to: “http://codecanyon.net/images/common/file_type_icons/.png”

