Thanks felt!
Hello,
A vh customer bought a regular license to run one of my template in a TV commercial.
My question is do he need a regular or extended license for a TV commercial use?
On VH items page it is clearly mentioned :
- Regular Licence a free to view video project (promotional, event, educational, client)
- Extended Licence a film or television production, commercial app, game or other software
BUT , in the license terms :
The Regular License could be used for any of the following:
1. Single advert, whether on radio, TV or the Internet…”
Also, does that apply to my AJ tracks? If anyone want to use our work in a TV commercial around the world he just have to purchase one regular license?
Thanks for your input!
Florian
AndrewDavies saidHe will need extended license (resale the work) only if he have a customization request. So it is easy to check in the “happy customers” section there is a couple of project that should have been sold, but I have no idea if this is VH projects… I noticed that in one of his demo he is using an audiojungle track with the watermark, idk if this is legal, but this is clearly not serious work… So we have to keep an eye on this website.
Hey Webarteo, if he needs an extended license to do what he’s doing then it’s definitely not legal since there’s no record of an extended license sale on any of my projects. Sending you the link now.
AndrewDavies said
I found another site that’s using my project along with a bunch of other VH and Revostock projects. His pricing on the “Pricing” page is between $150 – 450, which leads me to think that he’s intending to buy a project each time he makes a sale.
The owner of the website have to purchase an extended license on VH each time he do a customization, right? I am surprised by the low amount of extended licenses we sell on VH… (ratio is 1 extended for 50 regular licenses on my account) Also, could you please send me the link? Thanks in advance!
Thanks for the info… could you please send me the website address by pm? Thanks in advance!
marcanti said
As far as I know of, I’m respecting the extended license term in using templates in my video software. My laywer is currently reviewing the license terms, and if he finds that I am braking the terms, I will remove the 3 templates from videohive that I am using.
Be prepare to remove the other from Pond5. Staff and the authors have been warned.
marcanti said
Just sitting back after making the template and expect 50% cut of all Mp4 video sales is just not fair… That would be too easy for you, while I have to do all the hard work for making a sale and rendering a mp4 video. Comon, this is totally obvious and anyone with common sense will acknowledge this…
Nobody here will acknowledge this, because you are not respecting the rules. When a client create a video with one of our templates he must purchase the template, this is how it works.
You are in the same case.
marcanti said
The hard part is not making the template, it is making the sale!
Man, seriously, it is hard for you to make a sale when you offer $9 for some the best templates available?
marcanti said
And the reason it would sell 1000 mp4 files is not because of your amazing template, its because of my software and my efforts to find customers. You do absolutely nothing to generate these sales!
Envato too has a great infrastructure and advertising cost… and we have a 33 to 70% deal on each sell. Your effort to find customers consist of customize our products for a price inferior to what we can sell here, and make money with OUR products.
If our “amazing” templates you are using are not generating any sales, why keep them?
marcanti said
Bottom line: The market price for producing AE templates ranges from between $100 and $1000 per template, depending on the quality and complexiness… So It is out of proportion that in theory, you are asking for $30.000 if, through my hard work, I sell 1000 MP4 videos based on the template. You do absolutely nothing to generate these sales!!
You are using some of the best templates available, created by the best authors. Some of my templates create more than $10.000 of value just on the marketplaces and I do not count the value generated by clients, agency using our templates. And I am (very) small compared to elite author, I guess it can reach $30.000 on the templates you use from CreativeLab.
If you are as good in business as in programming you can easily take advantage of the situation and generate profit on your sales even if you pay per use. Prices on videohive are low, under $30, why you cannot fix a price that allow you to remunerate authors and generate profit for you? Instead of offer for customization some of my templates at $9 ? Honestly what you do is not fair.
