hi. I know there is no reviewer here. but you should know the reason of rejection. I’m sure that the reviewer accepts or rejects each item within a second and without posting the specific reason. all I think the reviewer thought so “well I didnt like than reject.”
OK you graphic experts (no reviewer please) I read all referral links about the quality etc.and etc. but I believe everything is ok with my item.what should be the reason the rejection of this file? any clue ? thanks https://www.dropbox.com/s/utk0nidjvzjvgxi/preview-onboard.png
If you want an honest, it looks like a very simple drawing. the shoulders are like they’ve been drawn in a matter of seconds (It may have taken minutes or hours to be done, but that’s how it looks) Your lines are consistent on line depth. Try give it some Pressure simulation. Shadows, totally not OK.
Other than these, I also suggest you to add more shadow and highlight layers on the character and give it some depth and some more details. It’s Way too flat and way too simple.
Demorfoza said most of it.
I suggest you to use designs that interact with your typography elements to make their presence not only aesthetic but also essential to the card,
I also suggest you to move all the contact info to the back face of the card alongside with the website address. and on the front face do not use fonts under 7pt.
You know now I’ve actually started the design it’s actually quite a lot different so I think it will have to be a new item. Otherwise it might loose sales if the public don’t like it as much. Plus I wonder if the reviewers would allow such a big design change.
I would suggest an update, but since the changes are significant that makes it a new Item, well, a new submission is certainly the best option. Laters on, you can give out a package containing the new and the old template if you feel the sales are dropping.
I uploaded this and other flyer’s see examples:http://cdn-files.creafx-static.com/files/12562.jpg http://cdn-files.creafx-static.com/files/12599.jpg http://cdn-files.creafx-static.com/files/12556.jpg
Got this feedback: Unfortunately your submission Futuristic Party Flyer GraphicRiver Is not ready for and can not be resubmitted as it did not meet our minimum requirements for quality and / or marketplace policies. In order for submissions to be Considered for sale they must be of high aesthetic and technical quality, unique to our library and can not be in violation of Envato’s policies. Please see our Knowledgebase for more information: http://support.envato.com/index.php?/Knowledgebase/List Our team Review Also provided These comments:
Unfortunately your submission does meet our current minimum technical requirements for the quality category it was to Stumbleupon. Please consider taking some time to Familiarize yourself with our current library and quality levels of popular items before resubmitting.
We appreciate your submission and look forward to seeing your future submissions.someone .. any advice?
Yeah. just what Demorfoza said in the other topic and I add, don’t post the same thing multiple times. Creating one single topic for a single problem is the best way to get the best result.
Ok why don’t you give me this feed back when you reject my files??? as a reviewer you should take the time to let us know what is wrong and yes on the second one the blur is because i use blur effects and they are not cheep they are all vector i can send you a copy of the bill from where i purchase the items … all i ask is to give me a feed back when rejected my files and no reply thats why i over react on this post i got your attention right?? that was my point because if we don’t get feed back on the flyers we don’t know what to do … Thank youDemorfoza said
I think you represent wrong attitude. At the very beginning you say that you’re 12 years in the industry, now that your flyers are better than the other present on martketplaces.
While I could agree with the second part in a fraction of cases, the first one does have nothing to do with being accepted.
I fell like you’re overreacting a bit, your flyers are not as good as you think. First of all – I already told you about lack of shadows, but you seem to not bother at all. I also told you about cheap-looking elements, which are ribbon and blurred pretzel and sausage on the third flyer.
Main title on the first flyer is too blurred and has too much unnecessary light on it. For me it’s also too small, but that’s subjective. All the texts – on both ribbons and elements – are not aligned with them. They have to appear as one element, now it’s just ribbon and some random text effect.
Fixing all the above would be a great start, keep calm
It’s a natural reaction to multiple rejection if you’re not familiar with the market place.
To be honest, Your first two flyers don’t have a chance with their current look. There are way too much to be improved that if done they will be totally new Items, but some authors such as Demorfoza already have given you good feedbacks. The third one anyway is better and needs some improvements.
• No matter if the shapes you use are vector or not, you have blurred them or they were blurry to star with, It doesn’t fit the theme. remove the blurry effect since it just ruins ‘this’ work.
• Bear, Live Music, parade… They look way too separated from the bottles. If they’re going to be there, at least make them look good, I’d suggest smart object with wrapper and some reflections as well (the same on the bottles) in order to blend them in.
• WAY TOO MUCH lighting. instead of some light they look like some blurry solid white shape. if you’re gonna use lights, I suggest you to play with colors and blending options. also remember, lights are like spice in food. Just a tiny bit is enough, very few people like too much spice and in a marketplace like this, majority are what you should have in mind.
• Your bottles seem like duplicates and just the label images have been changed. sometimes making some little changes in duplicated Items will help make it look better.
• Labels look too flat on the bottles. hint: If there is reflection of lights and shadows on bottles, why not to let them have some effects on the labels as well? Just have the material type and respond to light in mind.
Please regard this that this is a marketplace, not a graphic school, and reviewers job is to review not to teach. It took 10-15 minutes of my time to point out some and not all of your best flyer out. All of them together would take like an hour for a reviewer. Please have in mind that they have to review lots of Items on a daily basis and they can’t spend even 5 more minutes than what they spend to check your files on Items that are having too much problems. If it’s just a text or a minor design, they’ll point it out for you on a soft reject.
I suggest you to stick with your third Item for now and after you improved it and resubmitted, then work on the other two or even a new one.
have a great time.
Using bevel, Stroke and outerGlow all at once on same item Doesn’t fit for this theme. Your flyer doesn’t have consistancy. At some pooints you see sharp texts with high contrast and at some other points we see a Noisy-painting style background with design shapes not as sharp as the text and with very low color, and edge contrast. The country Night color and style doesn’t match up with the background color.
Overall, as an observer, it hurts my eyes and is hard to concentrate and read.
Good to see you can’t take criticism. How about you stop wasting reviewers time and actually improve on it? Grow up.
I’d just like to say that I think the reviewers gave a lot of constructive criticism here and made the right points quickly. I do think the final result of the review ended in a huge oversight as being thanked for your help doesn’t fit with “grow up” in reply… I see a huge language barrier, can you now? “Reviews will improve re-evaluating. Thank you ..” translates to “thanks for your help, I will re-evaluate my design and try to improve it.” I may be missing it completely but that’s what it reads like on this objective end. I thought you might want to know.
Seconded. From what I read on GokhanKara’s last comment, He meant a thank you and showed some appreciation.
Hi everyone i was hoping to get some guidance. Ive created two similar flyer templates for the month of February but i was wondering although they look somewhat identical ..except that fact they both have different elements would they both get approved or would will envato likely reject it due to the fact they look similar to each other.. I decided not to include them both in one file because they have more than a handful of different elements.
Technically they are two different Items with same Style of design, so it should not be a problem, but to take the safe side, I suggest you to not limit the differences to the contents, but as well to color themes. For example if they both are blue, make the other one red. Better safe than sorry.
yet on the other hand, if you place them both in same file (If both are related by subject), It’s true that the price might ot change, but the chances of them being sold will be higher.
You can post a message in their comment to ask or directly go to their support page http://themeloy.com/support/ or click on their username icon on the right side and send them a message (located in the bottom right side of screen) to send them an email through envato and receive the reply on your email.
Why won’t you just learn illustrator instead of trying to go around it? trust me, it will serve you a lot better.
I know how to use AI. I’m just asking if EPS/PSD is enough or should I do the whole design in AI instead of PS. but never mind. I’ll do them in AI just to be sure.