I think thats a correct price for that file.
Collis mentioned him at the Q&A videos. He also told us that they made fake accounts to talk with him XD
Edit: there you go. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RrQS-Mu2-X0&list=UUJr72fY4cTaNZv7WPbvjaSw&index=16
I think everyone wants to be a themeforest author. But If im right at the PSD templates the quality level must me very very high to be applied. THEN start to code the HTML version of that PSD, and after your HTML is approved for sale, go ahead for WP. ( I guess this is the correct process )
What a rip-off. They could buy a license for just a few dollars.