Football, running, fitness, cycling, tennis and hiking are my favs
What did reviewer say? Is this a single page design? Why do you have “designed with love by haintheme” in footer?
As reviewer said, the design is not good enough to be accepted. But standards under PSD category are very high, so you need to improve it and resubmit.
a) Bad design – Hard reject
b) Better design but nothing special – Hard reject
c) Good design with some flaws – Hard reject (I could tell how to get this approved message)
d) Good design – This could be accepted under HTML with some imrpovements…
e) Great design with few flaws – Soft reject
f) Great design – Approved
From what I read here and from my few soft and hard rejected items here under PSD section…
You need to keep working on the item, and eventually you will get to the level reviewers demand. If you want, you can show us the design and we can critique it.
The new PSD preview is useless. Before the change, I could see everything without a single click – thumbs were small, but you could see the structure. People before me have highlighted all the problems and I agree.
I know you wont be switching back to the old way, but please consider making it optional for PSDs, something like http://i.imgur.com/fNS4l9G.jpg
Thanks Vikram. Yeah, I’m aware of all those points stated and blame them for the rejection. Actually, I’m grateful that it was rejected, otherwise I wouldn’t learn, I’ve got few glitches I carry around constantly
It took 5 days, reviewers aren’t quick ATM so anything below that should be a suprise. Good luck with your item.
I’ve got first hard rejection, but really didn’t think it will come to that. I’ve used more conservative style, not everything blown out of proportion, but I guess there’s no room for that in PSD category anymore. This would get approved under HTML as reviewer said, but not enough for PSD section. I’m looking for some tips what did go wrong. I have the idea how to get it accepted, but as I spend lots of time making the style I wanted, it would be sad to do that.
Anyways, there are 16 PSDs, this is just one of the homepages, but every page follows the style.