I think this is must. From my experience, if I always read the reviews before purchase something and I can see the reasons for all those with 1 star. If there are good reasons to have 1 star, then I don’t buy the product, else if there are unjustified reasons then for sure I’ll ignore these ratings and buy it if other reviews are good. Envato we need this, I need this.
Every product has its own dedicated forum, where everyone is free to comment on, and discuss the product. product reviews, questions and feedback are often discussed there.
Just a suggestion: don’t call them support packs, call them service packs. Then we can have “installation/setup service packs” and “customization service packs”.
This kind of reminds me of one of the stories in freakonomics, where a daycare had problems with some parents picking up their children late. So they decided to charge a little extra if you picked up your child late. Seems simple enough: charge the late parents more, they’ll learn their lesson, and start coming on time. But the opposite happened, more parents started picking up their children much later, and they felt justified doing so because they were “paying” for it anyway. The point I’m making is that humans can be unpredictable, especially where behavior, money and motivation are concerned. The changes mean well, but may not produce the results you expect. This is not just another cosmetic change like designing new badges or changing layouts. It has the potential to completely change the nature of this marketplace, either for better or worse. Danger ahead, listen to the community, and proceed with caution.
Congrats Amaski! But it’s no longer called the black paw, its now called “same color paw – level 4”
Buyers shouldn’t buy based on our badges. They should buy on the our file’s quality. They shouldn’t care if author sold many or too little items, where they’re from or if they’re elite or not.
I’m sorry but as a buyer on themeforest I must say I always prefer to buy items from authors with proven sales, high-rating, etc. If they have badges for involvement in the community or blogs or articles, much better.
Why? Because an item with 1000 sales means quality. 1000 people can’t be wrong, don’t they? I have seen new themes rated with 5 stars, from new authors, but they did not work in all browsers or they blocked my phone. So, how can be the quality proved?If you buy a car for instance, why you prefer to buy it from a branded company, with many years of experience and many sales and proven quality? Why not buy then a no-name car?
Yes, but why the ugly?
At the moment, we’re not requiring that the entire set of PHP coding rules, as outlined for WordPress, be followed. We’re specifying a couple of them that we do require in order to improve legibility of code. If it would be easier for you to simply follow them wholesale though, then by all means, please do!
The tabs one is a bit tricky, as wordpress does it differently from most other big PHP projects. I’m seeing a situation where I’ll have to adjust my editor every time when switching between creating themes/plugins for here, and working on other projects. If its about legibility, then how about a compromise, like for indenting, use 1 tab OR 4 spaces. Unless of-course you do plan to require full compliance to the wordpress style-guide, then it doesn’t really matter what rules you choose to start with.
I have a question. Do we have to really follow this: http://make.wordpress.org/core/handbook/coding-standards/php/#brace-style I don’t like my braces with unnecessary spaces.
Same question here. Are the wordpress PHP formatting rules meant to be followed in full, or are just bits of the rules being picked? If the whole standard must being followed, so be it. But if just a few specific rules are being selected from there, then please don’t pick the most controversial rules. Like the tabs vs spaces issue, a debate that’s been going on since programming started.
And about envato censoring comments, do this little exercise: Look for items with a 1 star ratings, then go through their comments sections.
So your comments got removed. It may or may have not been justified, but just because you don’t agree with the decision taken in that one instance, it doesn’t mean the whole system is flawed, or that envato has conspired to “silence all buyers”.
pjtops saidOf course it does, but it doesn’t have a customer feedback section and it’s not an online marketplace, so the comparison isn’t really relevant.
Does your business have a website? Cause if you do, I’m sure all the content there has also been “pruned to the benefit of the seller”.
A “customer feedback section” is not an “anything goes section”, and a business has the right to decide whats acceptable on its own website. And if your business is selling something, then that’s very relevant because the definition of a marketplace is that its somewhere where goods and services are sold.