It is only the same as on here. Sometimes on the forums even top designers wonder why there logos are rejected and then go on to say they have sold it on another site for a lot of money.
Things are subjective and it is always down to the reviewer what is accecpted for sale. Sometime you might not agree with it but it is there site in the long run.
It is true, letsjustdesign Originally with just two sales and the files uploaded it would be easy for Envato to think well it must me one of those two… but they just ask you to send out a DMCA…
Was going to add a 200 piece boards game series of templates, floorplans tokens etc for wargames but might just do it myself now.
I can individually identity mark each copy sold them so would not immediately if they appeared on a free site who I sold them to. Such a shame really, as you say especially all the work that goes into our work.
Getting them to respond to DMCA is sometimes impossible…. Some have no contact details other thee hosts are less than helpful. Trying at the moment but it takes time.
another 3 download sites now, which is a pity as it has been downloaded 23 times on them….
you would hope that with only two sales Envato would have a clue as to at least one of the people involved….
Pretty Speedy! Already my Collectable Card Game Template Pack [link removed]
Is already on 3 download sites… Now it only has had two sales so it have to be one of those people who has uploaded it. Does not seem much point in working so hard to get stuff ripped off so quickly..
Lots of little edits and wait and a lot of patience by the reviewers and we are finally there. The collectable card templates are final live. Cheers for everyones help and advice.
Had a simiar thing.http://graphicriver.net/forums/thread/card-design-suggestions/108139
Senior review tells me to upload again after a tweek as the file is approved…. 19 days later it is soft rejected again because now in a different category….
Don’t seem able to win with this one….
Regards your item Collectable Card Game Template Pack Management has looked over your file and are happy to approve it if you update the item description to be clear on how the item is constructed and the level of editability.I am now told….
Soft Rejected Reason: To be accepted in the Design Templates category, files must be prepared for printing. This includes bleeds and trim guidelines, font documentation, prepared in CMYK (and not RGB) and 300dpi (instead of 72DPI). Your file may not have included one or more of these standards. Please prepare your file with printing standards in mind. Additionally, the background of the design should extend to the very edge of the art board, including bleed and cut guidelines.
So I am either now in a new category or have to make more changes. If that is so what not tell me that at the beginning?
I have one for 16 days and one for 7 at the moment. admittedly they are little changes but I was told both would be updated and approved as they review team (support ticket team had checked and approved them)....