Your WP theme looks very feature rich as per the description and the pages layouts – in my opinion. However, some design finishes and polishing will make it ready for ThemeForest. Personally, I would recommend appropriate selection of content images to add more meaning to the theme (and for buyers to visualise better), and also use varied colors instead of one-tone. You have color preview panel, maybe you could use something else as default to have more impact.
Also, you need to explicitly answer the important question: “How is your item unique and value added?”.
It can be frustrating to have your items rejected – but I see that you’re positive. The key is to keep trying and improving by seeing the existing approved items in the marketplace.
All the best.
Review teams do a great deal of effort to provide feedback as close as they can, and in most cases they even provide very specific feedback.
As the quality standards of the Envato marketplaces are very high, they are unable to provide feedback if you are very far from meeting their expectations. For example, if your template does not meet a lot of requirements, they cannot provide feedback and it is recommended to do your own study by reviewing the existing items and understanding the lack.
It could really be frustrating to have your templates rejected, especially with the extremely high requirements. I highly advice going through a few of existing items and check them in terms of responsiveness, retina clarity, trendy art & design and more, to adapt to the group established standards.
Wish you the very best – the secret is to keep your cool and keep trying.
Hey Mate – the app is awesomely feature-rich! Nice Work!
It is common to find an app for authors, but really never seen an app for both authors as well as users to browse all envato marketplaces – I rated 5 stars for you!
P.s.: I really like how you show sales notifications/updates in the App.
Wow! An amazing milestone achieved, impressive!