Please don’t call out others, nobody but the author you called out really cares, but you’ll only get yelled at by the Envato staff.
Nice public whois script by the way, I’ve seen it before. Not sure why your script is being rejected, perhaps you can open a ticket with Envato support requesting more information from the reviewer?
Pretty disappointing that the reviewer isn’t providing any comments.
You clearly have a misunderstanding on what a sale reversal is.
The person who bought your item goes to their bank and says “this was not an authorized charge” or disputes it and the bank gives them the money back. There is no fixing this. Envato therefor reverses the sale on your statement, too, because they don’t want to buy your item.
I browse themeforest regularly as a regular buyer.
I usually just hover over the thumbnails and look for the design in the preview image. If the theme design isn’t in that preview image, too bad for them. I’m not wasting my time to click onto their item page and view it.
Every theme I’ve ever bought has the preview in the preview image.
Really?:/ It’s your choice but why do you use a vulnerable security plugin? I saw in the comments the plugin is still vulnerable and envato/author don’t care about this. I don’t know the author but it looks like he is far away from coding.
Envato takes down the item if they find a vulnerability – which you saw happen twice. It cannot reappear on the market until said vulnerability is fixed by the author and confirmed by Envato.
I don’t think you’ll get hard rejected, it looks pretty good.
I don’t charge any money for customizations (I do small customizations for free, if it’s too big I won’t do it) but it is completely allowed.
From the perspective of a buyer (Chrome Browser)..... Compare your theme to that of many themes already here. Yours looks old and outdated.
First, what are those ugly icons at the top right? Judging from the code they should be social buttons but I see some really weird content instead. After clicking to another page it fixes, but if I refresh the issue reappears. Not sure if this is an issue with my browser.
Second, looks like you have some padding issues. Things are not spaced very well.
Font doesn’t seem too consistent, colors are boring, you used an image for the gradient background in your header which I don’t think I’ve seen on themeforest for a while.
Forms aren’t consistent either, and don’t look too good. Footer on the “under construction” page is messed up. There’s many more flaws.
Simply put, your theme looks rushed. It doesn’t look anything like what themeforest generally approves, in my opinion. Hopefully a designer can chime in and give you some specific suggestions.