22 posts
Item was Featured Author was Featured Referred at least one person Sold between 1 000 and 5 000 dollars Bought between 10 and 49 items Russian Federation
relplus says

Greetings to all! I the first time write here, but on very important subject. Mine (PSD) file has been rejected just, but the main reason not in it, i wish to discuss globally some things. Fortunately, i not from those people who simply have still no developed feeling of harmony, but thus ask to explain, why their ugly file is rejected – really that here will tell. At me absolutely other situation, opposite – I have understood, what my file is too good to be here??. It shocks. I do not wish to trust in it. I am simply enamoured in Envato, it is the best marketplace which i saw ever, but it now simply breaks off to me heart.

I will pass to an essence. (Pictures in the end of the post) The file reason for rejection was such: “However, we’ve determined that it feels a bit dated, and would be difficult to convert to HTML and CSS .”

- What it is difficult for converting, i do not deny – but why here there should be only simple things??.

- Difficult, but it is possible – i did it, it not so is difficult as it seems. And, besides. Why the dear inspector has decided, what people for simple designs here will always come? Here i for example, wished to buy something here for a new blog which needed to be made faster, than i would draw it. But i so also have not chosen anything – all here too simply for me. (i ask nobody to take offence, brothers – simply i like another. Your works are good in own way) And time is i, means is and much others who thinks as. I think, Envato loses many profit, simply cutting something in spite of the fact that it is beautiful, but is difficult..

- I who has “outdated” here has understood so that, apparently it WEB becomes outdated!! Represent, what paradox?. Apparently, now in a fashion simple forms, like-a-just-rectangles, and difficult original designs is has become outdated?. To what we will come then. There can be opposite, a web future behind original, man-made, unique things? I also try to do such, and i had big plans on replenishment ThemeForest by these interesting works. But it turns out, it has become outdated, and the future behind limiting simplicity?. As it is a pity! Let’s change it!..

Envato, please, believe to me. I simply wish to receive here “ticket” for loading of these “difficult” things – let’s look together that from this it will turn out. Do not narrow the market to those who has no “too much mind” for difficult work – let in here and professionals – i simply feel that they go here, but do not find that it to buy, as i have not found also – probably, they wait for more difficult things more detailed, more jeweller.

And here examples: Sample 1 It is that file which has been rejected for the specified reason. Really it too difficult??.

Sample 2 It is one of files which i wished to send later, having changed it is it works on mine home-page now

Sample 3 Following, experimental template which i have half finished and as it was ready to send here.

Sample 4 Sample 5 Still pair of examples of “uneasy” design

Please, Envato, believe to me and believe in these people who for the present are not present here (just because you do not trust in their ability). Doing the reason for a deviation “it it is too difficult” real, you simplify yourselves to certain borders, it is very sad.

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
22 posts
Item was Featured Author was Featured Referred at least one person Sold between 1 000 and 5 000 dollars Bought between 10 and 49 items Russian Federation
relplus says

..if to tell shortly, the inspector has rejected “too difficult file” – but I was intend to deliver here such works, because this mine favorite a direction, and Envato – mine favorite sites. Therefore I would like to think that it was only opinion of the person, but not the Companies. (Forgive, brother JeffreyWay, but I would not buy any file from as what you consider as the best (and has collected in a collection) – and there are many other people thinking as. These files perfectly approach for corporate-style, and at you good taste about it but how to be with underground, experimental, creative, hand-drawing sites, and those who wishes them to receive?.)

(..and forgive me for bad English:)

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
656 posts
Exclusive Author Item was Featured Author was Featured Author had a File in the Birthday Bundle Referred at least one person Sold between 10 000 and 50 000 dollars Bought between 10 and 49 items United States
jonathan01 says

@relplus – you need to look around the designs for sale here at TF and notice the quality of work and style of templates that sell.

This style is not going to sell – and I do not think any company would want to buy for a corprate site.

Take a look around the site and see the style that are selling and this will give you a good basis as to what to aim for.

You can also use http://reviewmydesign.net/ to get feedback from TF authors prior to submitting. But right now I have to agree with the reviewer.

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
24 posts
Exclusive Author Canada
NathanCH says

I can see why these were rejected. They’re outdated in that the styles are reminiscent of the early 2000s. And yes, that makes it hard to slice up without having tons of tiny images.

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
22 posts
Item was Featured Author was Featured Referred at least one person Sold between 1 000 and 5 000 dollars Bought between 10 and 49 items Russian Federation
relplus says

Yes, guys – you only confirm my fears.

jonathan01 * > you need to look around the designs for sale here at TF

It explains nothing. As on TF something is on sale only from this that APPROVE on TF. If here there was an alternative, still it is not known that would be bought better.

NathanCH* > I can see why these were rejected. They’re outdated in that the styles are reminiscent of the early 2000s.

It means only that in 200th designs were better! And now web degrades, and I just here try to resist to it.

We take one work from your bookmarks: http://themeforest.net/item/blue-planet/43080

What do we see there?. A rectangle. The rounded off rectangle. Other rectangle. – Is a DESIGN ?. You know, how rectangles are called – are PRIMITIVES . Same there is also a design today – it is primitive!

And yes, that makes it hard to slice up without having tons of tiny images.

- And just all also explains it – LAZINESS ! Tons of small pictures – yes! But it just that does work unique that does its interesting. And that does by its WORK , instead of an excuse. As I see, today all have grown lazy, and all works of these lazy children are similar AGAINST EACH OTHER .

Envato, wake up! Let’s not degrade…

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
onuro says

@relplus: Despite I agree with others that this design wouldn’t sell much here, I’m with you on this one.

Approvals must not be the related to the style of the item, but the design quality.

Leaving my personal above idea aside, TF & Envato holds the right to what to pass and what not; which also means has the ability to set the defining style for the marketplace and reject any item that does not fit in with the overall style.

Additional: As mentioned almost on every topic related to TF quality guidelines, I have to agree that there are still many horrible layouts & designs that are passed through [some of which even get featured from time to time].

It’s like any highschool student with a bit knowledge of css and a few techiques coming from design tutorials can put up items for sale.

Someone has to draw the line between the pros and amateurs.

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
22 posts
Item was Featured Author was Featured Referred at least one person Sold between 1 000 and 5 000 dollars Bought between 10 and 49 items Russian Federation
relplus says

thanks, onuro

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
319 posts
Author was Featured Referred at least one person Sold between 1 000 and 5 000 dollars Bought between 10 and 49 items Ireland
musicformedia says

You have some cool designs, but I think the reason they rejected them is that theres a lot of people who like to buy templates on here (like myself sometimes) and edit them to suit their own website. Some of your websites are a little too complicated in terms of imagery etc. to edit easily, so maybe that might be one of the causes?

They’re cool templates, but if you take a look around themeforest, it looks like they like simple and elegant themes which are easily editable, compared to themes which are not as easily editable.

Maybe I’m wrong, just my 2 cents :)

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
29 posts
Exclusive Author Bought between 1 and 9 items United Kingdom
sean14592 says

I have only tried to submit once and it was rejected.

Try coding the design and resubmitting it as a web template, maybe you will get more luck that’s what I’m trying.

Sean

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink
twiroo says

?? ?- ????? ????, ?? ?? html ?? – ? ?? ??? ???? ?????. ?????, ?? ? ? ????? ???? ?? ? ????? – ????? ???.

???? ? 80% ??? ??????? ????? ? ?????.

Posted 8 months ago Report | Permalink

Active Threads