Maybe something like this:
Most Original Profile
Rising Star (new Author)
Nice!! But look at the sales and not a on the amount of dollars earned….
Nominated for “Most annoying user in the past year”: Doru
I’m hoping to get the forum troll award
But seriously, I think what would be really cool is if nominees for awards were selected by Envato.. and then voted by the community to decide who wins. Maybe with live voting results for a week or something, could be fun!