19 posts
  • 2 Years of Membership
  • Author Level 5
  • Affiliate Level 1
  • Collector Level 2
+1 more
DiamondTheme
says

We have uploaded our one-page theme “WindCake” but it was hard-rejected. Need some inputs from themeforest authors on what might be the reason for rejection.

Demo URL : http://we-biz.biz/windcake/blue/

1642 posts
  • Elite Author
  • Featured Author
  • 7 Years of Membership
  • Author Level 11
+8 more
fuelthemes
says

Just a personal preference, but the slider is very awkward. When you click on next, it does not have a transition.

1763 posts How's the surf doing?
  • Power Elite Author
  • Trendsetter
  • Top Monthly Author
  • Community Superstar
+10 more
tommusrhodus
says

Quite severe scroll lag in Safari 7.0

356 posts
  • Affiliate Level 2
  • Author Level 5
  • Beta Tester
  • Collector Level 3
+4 more
cosmincotor
says

A reason should be included in your rejection email, so make sure you check it.

The template is not bad, try to remove that custom scroll bar because it affects performance in some browsers, and improve the slider and portfolio.

Add some effects to the slider, it’s just too simple now, and maybe some lightbox/details window for each portfolio item.

Good luck! :)

25 posts
  • Affiliate Level 3
  • Author Level 6
  • Collector Level 4
  • Most Wanted Winner
+3 more
WS-Theme
says

The Map with the Overlay looks not very well … and maybe you have to add more Color Options in the Switcher?! Also the Testimonial Section looks really strange on a large display! But nice Theme …!!

296 posts
  • Weekly Top Seller
  • Author Level 5
  • Featured Author
  • 6 Years of Membership
+4 more
CodeFusion
says

I’m not a TF author so I don’t know what constitutes a hard vs soft rejection; but design wise, here is what I see:

  • Slider text hard to read – maybe “soften” the images to help the text stand out.
  • Services: The image bg transition and the h4 color change are not in sync – feels clunky. Probably don’t need to change the color of the h4 beings as the img bg changes.
  • Services: at min-width one line of text wraps under image
  • Prices: Again, different (or lack of) transition on all the elements
  • Testimonials: The “width” does not match anything else – white space on left & right when viewed with 32” screen. The Slider and Map are full width – but the testimonial slider comes up short (too small/narrow of bg image). Maybe do a overflow hidden to match column width or make image bigger/wider to take up full screen width.
  • Testimonials: at min-width h1 line breaks
  • Testimonials: at min-width Prev / Next almost cover testimonial_title
  • Team Members: at min-width title line breaks
  • Contact: same transition thing as “Services”
  • Blog: Post Meta: hover to unhover – bottom border disappears while color is still in transition.
  • Blog: at min-width “Post Title” breaks line
  • No “back to top” and/or sticky menu – bad UX for really long pages. – I feel “stuck” and have to manually scroll – a lot.
  • The page “jumps” right – scroll bar
  • Responsive: menu different order than non-responsive (blog in middle versus end)

These design things seem rather trivial to call for a hard rejection. Maybe have a look at: http://support.envato.com/index.php?/Knowledgebase/Article/View/472/85/wordpress-theme-submission-requirements and make sure your theme is compliant – I’m pretty sure that “violating” one or more of those would cause a hard rejection.

I really like the theme – especially the colors!

4948 posts Community Mod Building awesome stuff for your mobile devices!
  • Trendsetter
  • Weekly Top Seller
  • Elite Author
  • Author Level 8
+17 more
Enabled
Moderator
says

I stopped making a habit from replying to these threads, but I really like your theme, so here’s my two cents on it!

  • on my 1920 display the text is out of center on the image slider
  • The custom scroll is annoying, to say the least!
  • Typography for the under slider columns needs improvement, if not for the headings the paragraphs for sure! Try a line height of 18 – 20 22 px , and the font size at least 12 pixels for paragraphs!
  • The price boxes shadow is too hard on my eyes at least, they look … sort of unfinished, like they need some polishing! Maybe the text under basic premium ultimate a little wider! Same goes for font size, line height improvements and font size improvements
  • The buy now buttons from the boxes, maybe a little smaller, the font a little smaller as well, at the moment, when looking at it, all that pops in my eye is buy now and the image, the text is invisible
  • Testimonials section, make the background fullwidth, the bleed margin on the sides look strange! For me at least
  • Team members section, I would personally make the text in it a little more compact, the margin between the box and text of 20 30 pixels!
  • The bottom contact section looks rather incomplete, some social icons a contact form, some contact information would make it sweet!
  • Other than that, I really like it! Good luck with “fine tuning it” mate!

This is my personal opinion as an author, not as an Envato representative, my opinion does not guarantee the item’s approval!

Later Edit: CodeFusion has some great opinions as well!

4379 posts
  • Affiliate Level 2
  • Beta Tester
  • Collector Level 2
  • Community Superstar
+7 more
Dzinc
says

This thread is now in › Item Discussion

19 posts
  • 2 Years of Membership
  • Author Level 5
  • Affiliate Level 1
  • Collector Level 2
+1 more
DiamondTheme
says

Thanks to @fuelthemes, @TommusRhodus, @cosmincotor, @WS-Theme , @CodeFusion and @Enabled for taking time and giving out valuable suggestions. It really motivates a new author.

Envato community is great. Special thanks to @Enabled

We will do all the changes requested by the authors here and submit the theme again.

44 posts
  • 2 Years of Membership
  • Kenya
ParallaxSecond
says

that template is awesome, why was it rejected? maybe you have not taken license’s considerations serioulsy. AS far as it validates on W3C, work on the gmaps footer section it’s really annoying. The only transitions am seeing are for the headings/titles, don’t limit yourself on transitions, make the page interesting. just my opinion though.

by
by
by
by
by
by