This was the file (the demo page):
It basically allows you to scroll any content without any clicking, dragging, or scrolling controls of any kind.
So anyway, it was rejected, but now I see this new item uploaded today:
TO MODERATORS : No, I’m not in any way trying to criticize this item, it works great. I’m merely using it to make a point.
IMO I gotta give it to you, if the approved similar functioning one is live, yours should be too, which both deserve to be in the market.
There are a lot of other items in here, some of which are even worse than free stuff on the web anyways.
- Envato Staff
- Repeatedly Helped protect Envato Marketplaces against copyright violations
- Has been a member for 5-6 years
- Microlancer Beta Tester
- Sold between 10 000 and 50 000 dollars
- Exclusive Author
- Interviewed on the Envato Notes blog
In my opinion, your item is better than the “handscroller” item, and therefore I see no reason to reject yours and approve the other one..
Also, the connection between the reviewer who reviewed your file, and that new file is an obnoxious one, I’m not accusing him of anything, but there is an obvious link..
- Sold between 50 000 and 100 000 dollars
- Has been a member for 4-5 years
- Referred between 50 and 99 users
- Bought between 10 and 49 items
- Contributed a Tutorial to a Tuts+ Site
- Author has had an Item Featured
- Exclusive Author
- United States
First of all, I honestly think your file should be approved. It’s very useful.
Second of all, as I recently found out, reviewers don’t review their own work.
Then it should be the reviewer who reviewed the reviewer’s work, that should review blabus’s item. Uh, did I make myself clear ? =)
Then it should be the reviewer who reviewed the reviewer’s work, that should review blabus’s item. Uh, did I make myself clear ? =)Another Paradox?
Hehe, But in the other topic, it says the other reviewers take care of the reviewers’ files.. So, JimmyP’s file should’ve been approved by Jeffrey
Another Paradox? Hehe, But in the other topic, it says the other reviewers take care of the reviewers’ files.. So, JimmyP’s file should’ve been approved by Jeffrey
Well that’s even worse then, since Jeffrey himself looked at my file as well. This was the email I got (I sent in another item as well):
I just showed these items to James, our scripts reviewer. We both felt that they’re not quite what we’re looking for on ThemeForest. For example, the navigation slider isn’t full-featured enough. A simple Google search produces plenty of free results.
I’m sorry that you had trouble uploading; however, these will need more work before being sold with us.