Since the beginning of days we’ve seen the “nice!” comments. Just noticed a new one/author ‘k’ (europe). I also just noticed two of these type of comments on a new item which doesn’t even work. Not the first time though. And I know it’s been discussed a zilion times. Anyhow, I seriously think that this ‘marketing technique’ actually works. And it’s pretty tempting to test it out, even though most people may frown upon it.
I was wondering, anybody willing to share experience on how effective they have found it to be?
- United States
- Has been a member for 4-5 years
- Exclusive Author
- Author was Featured
- Sold between 50 000 and 100 000 dollars
- Item was Featured
- Contributed a Tutorial to a Tuts+ Site
- Author had a Free File of the Month
Avatars from authors who comment should not be clickable. Problem solved.
- Sold between 250 000 and 1 000 000 dollars
- Has been a member for 6-7 years
- Author had a File in an Envato Bundle
- Most Wanted Bounty Winner
- Interviewed on the Envato Notes blog
- Author was Featured
- Item was Featured
- South Africa
or authors can’t post comments on other authors files – only if they purchased the file
- Repeatedly Helped protect Envato Marketplaces against copyright violations
- Sold between 100 000 and 250 000 dollars
- Exclusive Author
- Author was Featured
- Item was Featured
- Beta Tester
- Has been a member for 3-4 years
- Spain
Proposal: every post on files or forum containing the word “nice” must be treated like spam, and so deleted. 
(this one the first, it contains “nice” once. No! twice!)
- Repeatedly Helped protect Envato Marketplaces against copyright violations
- Sold between 100 000 and 250 000 dollars
- Exclusive Author
- Author was Featured
- Item was Featured
- Beta Tester
- Has been a member for 3-4 years
- Spain
or authors can’t post comments on other authors files – only if they purchased the file
I should add: Authors with paws like Shreck can’t post. Never. Wherever. 
I’ve had experience. You could get away with it by saying stuff like, “I thought that I might buy this file, but I’m gonna think about it a little more. Eh… its a pretty good deal, considering it suits the needs of anyone who might need it. I’ll just wait for some sales, then I’ll have some money in my account.”
If you say that on every thread, and pay heed to what each separate sentence is suggesting, you might be able to get away with it and not have to worry about anyone saying that you weren’t being loyal to you words… still though. I’d be one to see right through its insincerity.
But if you’re willing to try it,
sentence one
(I thought that I might buy this file, but I’m gonna think about it a little more.)
explained
It would imply that you would at least have the basic thought of buying the file. Even if you weren’t serious about following through with it.
sentence two
(Eh… its a pretty good deal, considering it suits the needs of anyone who might need it)
explained
Good deal = cheap. anyone who might need it might consider it to suit their needs. Self explanatory.
sentence three
(I’ll just wait for some sales, then I’ll have some money in my account)
Implies exactly what it means. You’re an author who makes decent sales. Inevitably you will acquire some funds from sales. Simple.
I don’t do that stuff all the time unless I’m trying to make it obvious that I’m joking around. And yet, I end up leaving something worth saying still when I leave a comment on an author’s page who’s file is worth commenting on.
Good luck with your campaign on gaining funds and a reputation with the word, ‘annoying’ applied to it. 
Since the beginning of days we’ve seen the “nice!” comments. Just noticed a new one/author ‘k’ (europe). I also just noticed two of these type of comments on a new item which doesn’t even work. Not the first time though. And I know it’s been discussed a zilion times. Anyhow, I seriously think that this ‘marketing technique’ actually works. And it’s pretty tempting to test it out, even though most people may frown upon it.
I was wondering, anybody willing to share experience on how effective they have found it to be?
Personally I don’t have anything against the “nice” comments as long as they’re really ment to be “nice” comments. But if someone would post a “nice” comment on my file and it wouldn’t work, I’d be a bit pissed of :)).
Avatars from authors who comment should not be clickable. Problem solved.+1 but: the name of the author is still visible. and typing activeden.net/user/author_name wouldn’t be too hard
.
or authors can’t post comments on other authors files – only if they purchased the file-1 or +1
. I can’t make up my mind
.Do this, [(+)(-)0]
Avatars from authors who comment should not be clickable. Problem solved.+1
Totally agree with you!
