My theme was rejected and the reviewer gave me the following suggestion but I can’t figure out what it really means:
‘Unfortunately your submission doesn’t meet our current minimum technical quality requirements for the category it was submitted to. Please consider taking some time to familiarize yourself with our current library and quality levels of popular items before resubmitting.’
I need some help to know what went wrong. Check the link below. http://www.broomstickdesign.com/Broomstick_Sports/I am totally blank on what to improve in the theme. Any kind of suggestion will be really appreciated.
Regards
I looking only on header, Premium Themes looks like this http://www.x4-design.eu/files/pr.png ?
You have more more more to work on this project … Sorry but it’s not at themeforest quality
PixFee said
You have more more more to work on this project … Sorry but it’s not at themeforest quality
Um, obviously. You’re no more help than the reviewers. The OP is looking for details rather than additional reinforcements of what the OP’s already been told. If you have nothing more to offer, please refrain from posting. LOL .
BroomstickDesign said
I am totally blank on what to improve in the theme. Any kind of suggestion will be really appreciated.
Aside from what has already been pointed out…
You’ve got a giant hole in the right sidebar. That’s an eyesore IMO . Maybe fix that (even if it’s just the demo) ?
Remove as much inline CSS as possible?
Make code more semantic? A simple DOCTYPE does not a HTML5 document make IMO .
Did you WP enqueue all your CSS / JS?
Is your backend theme options panel user friendly and powerful? Don’t have one? Don’t resubmit again without it.
Look into making the design as “responsive” as possible (navigation, columns, images, video, etc) before resubmitting. For the people that want a “fixed” design, you can give them the option as many premium themes do by having an on/off switch for the “responsive” behavior in the theme options panel.
Page Builder? Custom Post Types? Unlimited Sidebars? Color Options without resorting to CSS all the time?
Why should anyone buy your theme over another? Distinguish yourself! 
Not meaning to offend but trying to be constructive. These are just some of the often expected / included in TF Premium themes.
@electronicpakrat
Thanks for the wonderful suggestion. My theme didn’t have the backend option panel. Everything on theme is widget and I created the theme that way.
It seems that i have to create the theme from scratch. Your suggestion was really helpful.
i personally think that your themes is good. try to change background image. and other small think to make it more premium fell. your themes is only lack of finishing touch. i have seen themes like yours, and its selling well. good luck!
You may find this helpful then – http://themeforest.net/forums/thread/optiontree-20/69067
