Which category or...

Hi everyone, yesterday I submited new css login and registration form: http://codecanyon.net/item/usable-css-login-register-form/3871191

But, it’s pure css – so css category. Today I developed a complete jquery/javascript validation and made it move with clean jquery effects. So, questions is:

Is it better to update actual version – with two variations: Pure CSS and With jQuery validation (and how about a price? I don’t want the item cost more money, maybe)

OR

Submit this jQuery version to Javascript Forms category? So there will be 2 items (in CSS and Javascript).

Thanks for help

I personally would probably submit a jQuery version separately and in your description have something like:

“looking for a jQuery version? click here” and so on.

Go for a separate version, when the javascript takes an important part, it should be in the JS category (and I guess that it would be rejected in the CSS section for that reason).

Additionnally, you could face a rejection in the JS category aswell if you submit something “too simple” (I experienced it). It looks like there’s place only for items that are either complete jquery scripts / plugins OR 100% CSS. But a CSS element improved with javascript doesn’t fit anywhere…

woo i’m surprise that how envato approved this, but anyways make sure to remove your link, because no self-promoting allowed.

walidsu said
woo i’m surprise that how envato approved this, but anyways make sure to remove your link, because no self-promoting allowed.

It’s fine to post a link for feedback.

Thanks everyone, I’ll go for separate version than.

walidsu said
woo i’m surprise that how envato approved this, but anyways make sure to remove your link, because no self-promoting allowed.

I’m sorry, I thought about it, but didn’t realize. Definitely don’t want to self-promote.

Pixelworkshop said

walidsu said
woo i’m surprise that how envato approved this, but anyways make sure to remove your link, because no self-promoting allowed.

It’s fine to post a link for feedback.

last time they removed mine in sec .

Make-It-Real said
Thanks everyone, I’ll go for separate version than.

walidsu said
woo i’m surprise that how envato approved this, but anyways make sure to remove your link, because no self-promoting allowed.

I’m sorry, I thought about it, but didn’t realize. Definitely don’t want to self-promote.

i don’t care, i’m just saying that users should read the forum rules. as long as they don’t worn you.

Asking for feedback in the ‘Item discussion’ section is (and has always been) fine, nothing wrong with that. But there are users who flag any post containing a link.