Hello !My theme was rejected with this reply
Unfortunately your submission Respupr isn't ready for ThemeForest and cannot be resubmitted as it did not meet our minimum requirements for quality and/or marketplace policies. In order for submissions to be considered for sale they must be of high aesthetic and technical quality, unique to our library and cannot be in violation of Envato's policies. Please see our Knowledgebase for more information: <a href="http://support.envato.com/index.php?/Knowledgebase/Article/View/399/57/"> http://support.envato.com/index.php?/Knowledgebase/Article/View/399/57/</a>Do I understand correctly ?: At now I should to do follow 1. Go to the knowledge link 2. Find the my issue (In my case it is first item Your submission doesn’t meet our quality requirements) 3. Go to the link Quality Guidelines 4. And should do from the list “WordPress Theme Submission Requirements”
And I should not change my design. Only source code from my theme
Oh Thank you very very much !!! Your advices really great help me and now I know what I will do
I wish you many more great works
Hello My theme was rejected again with these reasons:
1) Many of the elements in the template are not aesthetically spaced. 2) The template’s overall typography isn’t yet ready. It needs improvements in the styles it offers and general visual hierarchy. 3) The template needs to offer more features, options and/or styled elements to be competitive in the marketplace.
And I understand nothing again .
Hello Theme-Titans Here are my observations:
Text in the slider not aligns well (example: the word “corporate” not fully visible in chrome and opera). And aligning of other items have no logics for me. I mean that h2 and h3 must be align by left or right side
Effect is good, but in chrome and opera text changes opacity fitfully
and may be little complicate all. add the prettyPhoto or Fancy , “transitions” for links from the menu or for others
Pasha with best regards
sorry for my english
thank you Theme-Titans for your feedback I thought about fonts and agree with you
About the black list thingy i don’t think tf does this, without authors they won’t be making any money, so i don’t really think such system exist.
May be black list is not right term. But very vague reviewer’s messages led me to this idea and I would be happy to be wrong
ashobiz SAYS Drop down navigation menu creating horizontal scroll bar…I see thank you. I’ll try it in less resolution of a monitor
ps the theme looks not too bad at all, seriously. just need some minor adjustments.Thank you for your support. I’ll do all of possible and impossible
Anps SAYS Get used to it… they rarley give detailed answeres, i use to be loud coz of that to but i learned that it is even better since they actually force you to research your imagination and skill and true that search you improve your self.I need to be patient
Thank you Anps for your great help!
Now I will work with titles, footer and other. But I don’t understand why the reviewer writes me not understandable messages instead of “you have ugly footer” or “ugly fonts” . By reason of such messages I start to think that reviewers don’t review my theme and merely reject it. And all of my attempts will be in vain.
Hello ! my theme was rejected again and now the reviewer wrote those rows
Unfortunately your submission doesn’t meet our current minimum technical quality requirements for the category it was submitted to. Please consider taking some time to familiarize yourself with our current library and quality levels of popular items before resubmitting.
up to the present moment the reviewer wrote me greater rows
Now I realy don’t know why they rejected me. May be they detect some small things in my theme and which I will never see. Or I am in some black list and reviewers never approve me and I must leave from TF in that case I think the reviewer have to tell me something like “your theme never be approve and stop work”. The reviewer gives me not a working links to support http://themeforest.net/support?sso and earlier I wrote a ticket and received the same meaningless answer.
Dear designer could you see my theme and tell me about my ugly things
thanks a lot
thank you very very much!!! Now everything is clear to me