I’ve heard electronica and trance tracks with similar electronic guitar tones. Reviewers have opinions and critique tracks as they see fit, doesn’t mean its a bad track. The guitar track doesn’t sound out of place to me, depending on the genre its set in, plus how open minded the reviewer is I’ve had my issues with review rejections (soft/hard), shake it off, make changes if you feel like it, then write more music to upload. Its their music library with a set agenda and guidelines, they’re out there to make money as a business, doing the best they can so we have to play by their rules to earn that cut. Good luck to you. Cheers!
What really problem with the reviewers is that they don’t have established system of requirements, design or exactly pointed quality. They are just free to use their personal judgmental do they personally like or not like the sound/sample/track, since here on AJ,there some is very low quality songs/samples/instrumental and I am not pointing on anybody, just making conclusion by hearing. Of course, I am not professional musician but I am not def as I can hear that also my track isn’t super super great quality but it has a really strong energy that is proven by posting on sound cloud and getting likes and shares….
The guitar samples do sound a bit “amateur” really. The song has great potential tho I think. Heres an idea: try doing a more electronic sound, replace the clean guitar sounds with electronic plucks or arps and the distorted parts with synth stabs. Do some sidechain pulsing, a stronger bass part and you’re all set! I know this might sound a bit drastic since you were going for more of an acoustic pop sound, but I believe the song would greatly benefit from an electronic approach. Good luck!
P.s. I’m originally a guitar player and I tend to be very strict when it comes guitar sound.
And try not to compare your sound design to the songs you think are of less quality.
Semblance, thank you for your time and opinion, I really appreciate. I never said that I am professional guitar player or musician I just like to compose and make something new.
I will try to take your advice but maybe not on this track since, as you notice, this is pop natural sound kind of track.
I had a small demotivation from AJ review team. What is about:
I uploaded this track: https://soundcloud.com/hello_charlie/play-with-pop-master-preview-aj
and I got soft rejection. Reason: Please remove/replace the electric guitar. It does not currently meet our samples quality standard.
This song is all about electric guitars and there is no instrument/synth that can give such pumping energy like electric guitars. I don’t wanna point finger in any author here but after that I have made a research and found a lot more worse electric guitar samples here but approved.
I am not deaf and I can here that samples in my track sounds very realistic.
What do you guys think about this song and reviewer’s comment?
Great feature and it’s works for me!
Very good quality, nice mate!
this is my song that I’m planing to upload on audiojungle.
If you have time, please listen to it and tell me your opinion, can this kind of music be successful on audiojungle?