It doesn’t make sense, Title is “TOP NEW AUTHORS in FEBRUARY ”, In my opinion the selection should be based on the activity Authors made in February, I Signed up in January First 2012, I am 1.5 Month old Author, I count this as a New User , This Works for me, It encourages me to submit better Item in each month.
No that’s not it, I had over 60 sales just for my february approved items, but I am not in, there should be something else I couldn’t figure it out.
ConstantinPotorac saidI appreciate every minute of your time constantin, the wonderful hard work you’ve been doing, you review files very professionally and It’s obvious you do it very accurately, not just by your feelings but also with your professional look. Wish we have more reviewer like you. Thank you
So many great stuff coming on. I have been reviewing like crazy lately. Can’t get any sleep here
P.s: I also had the most reasonable rejection from you
You can signup and they will send you an invitation within a week. Not that hard to get in.
I submitted a ticket to support about the reviewer taste approving issue, there is no such things in pro business. The reviewer should have specific explanations about rejections, not the cliché quality ones. I share my pro time with this website, this is my least expectations to know why my item get rejected. My rejected flyers had the design structures and concepts which I can’t see on some of the approved flyers.
This is the users’s choice to purchase what they like, but this is not the reviewer choice to reject the one they don’t like. I think in this case the reviewer should pass it to another with the checked box of “I don’t like this item what do you think?”.
Saying all of this because of unreasonable rejections, my iPresent family got hard rejected at first place,I didn’t really changed much but approved by other reviewer, now it hits the 120 of sale in less than a month, my other item Facebook board got hard rejected , now it hits the 40 sale after one week. I applied minor changes to item not to violate the policies but as the creator of the file I am completely aware of what it should look like and what should be inside.
There should be some badges shows that the author is professional or knows what he/she is doing. Maybe in that case the reviewer looks more accurate to item instead of their feelings.
This is a big issue for Envato , they should care about authors as they are the human resources of this marketplace, isn’t that what envato built on?
quickandeasy saidAaah, never caught the moment before approve/reject before, tnx for the info. How long does it usually takes? It’s been 15 minutes now.
aleluja saidThat most likely means it is being reviewed
Mine got held >_>
In this case it usually takes 24 hours at least. Mine got held once for an update.
I think Qualification and Eligibility is a MUST to judge other’s Design. a pro never judge but always suggest for improvements.