So as the topic says, what is Creattica standard by [edited by Drew – do not call out specific staff members], reviewer on Creattica; in this case for section Motion Graphics.
It’s not like I’m the only one having complains about it, so I would like to hear this directly from mentioned reviewer. Does only 3D-ish motion graphics projects go on Creattica? Can a single person make a solid decision what’s good and what’s not?
I am always for quality, don’t get me wrong. It’s case the case that this person is approving almost every 3D-ish project, but great 2D ones in most cases are rejected. This isn’t the case only with me, couple of guys from videohive told me this too, and their projects are just great.
I was in doubt lately if should delete my account there, but now it’s definite.
It’s not only issue with me, if you want creattica to stand out, you should be fixing this problem.
I have 2 Items 8 months ago, but it was REJECTED …
I had my 2.5D/pure AE project rejected but the 3D-ish one got in so it kinda confirms what Efekt’s saying. That kinda sucks coz there are wicked pure AE project here.
Thats it, my 3D files was approved, but my logos from my portfolio site was rejected.
I really did not understand My latest 3 work was rejected, magazine promo, blacknight 2 and today unitedmotions . Yeah I’m aware that my works are not the best but I can say they are standards are well above from creattica’s standards. Creattica is s part of envato network , so as we are !!! It would have better if they did treath us in a logical way.
I can’t see a stability in creattica’s quality standards !!!
I don’t get why are you guys so upset about this.
I Had submitted a 4 or 5 items there and all of them have been rejected. I believed that they were VERY good candidates to be on there but ultimately were not accepted. So I have decided not to spend my time submitting any motion graphics stuff over there since I see it as a waist of time and the likelihood of someone actually coming across a project that they want to buy is VERY VERY low.
@Drew – Calling out? I was just copy pasting the reviwer’s name from www.envato.com
I cannot see where is the problem? Anyway, you have one of the best authors here on videohive like Balistique and one of the BEST projects and also best selling ones that are rejected on creattica.
It’s your site, you obviously have a problem. But it doesn’t matter anymore I just deleted my account on creattica.
Not really sure what the deal is with Creattica. It doesn’t seem to make sense to anyone. I had the first few projects that I submitted approved, but after that, everything I submitted was rejected.
Of course, they don’t provide a reasoning for being rejected.
I’m sure it has something to do with them not wanting Creattica becoming a secondary marketplace for authors to sell their projects.
Anyway, I don’t waste my time with Creattica anymore. I don’t think there are a lot of customers browsing Creattica.com looking to buy projects. That’s what Videohive is for.