We had 2 themes soft rejected because of it, both cases we explained the reasons behind the solution:http://pastie.org/pastes/7122892/text?key=eqptyqa4qdmempics74xsa
and they were eventually approved.http://themeforest.net/item/hydra-fullscreen-portfolio-grid-wordpress-theme/history/4352507
We tested your theme very carefully with plenty popular plugins and everything seems to be working fine ..... Your solution seems to be a bit safer, but if we encounter any issue in the future we will soft disable and inform you about it.http://themeforest.net/item/bigwig-modern-corporate-retina-wordpress-theme/history/5217458
Confirmed by the team, you can use this code to clean up your shortcodes, but keep in mind that later this year shortcodes won’t be allowed in themes*. Good luck. * referring to phase 2 rules now postponed to > march 2014
I only posted item links in case review team wants to check the original discussion, i’ve also included some quotes from the reviewer (omitting the name), hoping that i’m not breaking any rule.
We’re still using the same solution since then and always include a reference to the above discussion in the message to the reviewer, themes have not been rejected for using that code anymore (last one being approved around 20 days ago).
Thanks bitfade for providing us with some background on this issue and the awesome piece of code. Much appreciated!
Hi again everyone,
I’ve discussed this with the Jarel and the Review Team, and we believe the BitFade’s proposed method is an acceptable approach.
I think it’d be ideal if functionality that modifies content or the_content filter was in a plugin, which could then be installed with the TGM Plugin Activation class, but that’s not a hard requirement at this point.
This is one acceptable approach, not necessarily the only accepted approach.
I hope that clarifies things for everyone!