I can only rate for one main reason, but to be honest, EvolveThemes deserve 5* for most of the elements of their Clayton Theme.
1) They have outstanding Service, support, team answering comments is always welcoming questions, I feel really at home opening a comment line
2) Updates : They listen to every single proposal from comments, see if it's interesting for them, they have an idea in mind, but really consider everything as a whole. Updates come at an incredible speed, timely, streamlined, no bugs. They are efficient, focused, business & client driven, not seen that with any of the themes I had purchased prior to Evolve
3) Website : Templates from the theme are easy to implement, no fuss, no pageBuilder. Using Wordpress Features, we know what we do is not lost, it's just showcased in a fantastic way.
4) Walls, albums, collections : What a brilliant idea ! simple to put in place, looks great, draws the eye.
5) Documentation is simple, easy to follow, and i'm only talking about the written one, I have not needed any of the Youtube channel to figure it out... Easy, simple, no wasted time !
Well, basically you get it... the theme is within the average price, and if you're questioning it, remember every minute spent on your website figuring things out, is money you're not earning with your business. Evolve has understood that, and allows us to get our business done, without fussing with pain in the butt coding (and i'm a former web developer).
Thank you !